THE HANGOVER REPORT – Bruce Norris’s unflinching drama DOWNSTATE arrives on Broadway as provocative, timely, and gripping as ever

Liza Colón-Zayas, Adrian Martinez, Francis Guinan, and K. Todd Freeman in Bruce Norris’s “Downstate” at the Booth Theatre (photo by Emilio Madrid).

Last night, Bruce Norris’s absolutely gripping “new” play Downstate opened on Broadway at the Booth Theatre. Norris’s drama has had an unusually lengthy gestation, having been originally staged in 2018 at Chicago’s famed Steppenwolf Theatre Company, where it was critically lauded. Much of the same cast subsequently traveled east with the Steppenwolf production for its 2022 New York premiere at Off-Broadway’s Playwrights Horizons, where it was met with equal acclaim and debate (a co-production with the National Theatre, the piece was also seen across the pond in London). Now the work debuts on the Great White Way, where it remains as timely as ever, particularly with respect to our current black-and-white cancel culture. Set in downstate Illinois, the play depicts a group of sex offenders, who, after having served time in prison, are housed together — with limited rights — and surveilled regularly by a probation officer who monitors and scrutinizes their every move. At the top of the play, the cogs of the drama are set in motion when one of the housemate’s victims, now an adult, visits their home to confront his abuser.

In short, Downstate is a stunner of a play — albeit a difficult and unflinchingly uncomfortable one to sit through. Like Norris’s previous plays (e.g., the Pulitzer Prize-winning Clybourne Park, The Pain and the Itch), the playwright’s latest is a caustic creation that’s been designed to induce strong reactions from audiences as it sheds a controversially sympathetic light on outcasts that society would rather not spend time dwelling on. Indeed, the work tests the limits of compassion and victimhood, pushing these typically clear-cut notions into slippery territory. Such murkiness goes a long way in highlighting the humanity in both the abuser and the abused. That Norris makes the effort to do so in the first place is a point of contention that will likely muster heated post-show discussions. Taking place mostly in real time, the play is a slow burn until it’s not. Although the first act may seem nothing more than a set up for the fireworks that crackle during the play’s incendiary second half, the overall construction of the piece is masterful, and Norris is keen to take a good hard look at each characters from all vantage points. In many ways, Downstate is a culmination of Norris’s craft as a playwright, the apotheosis of his singular ability to simultaneously shock and provoke thought — and in my estimation his finest work yet. For its Main Stem premiere, the production has been staged by the busy Joe Mantello, taking on directorial duties from Norris’s frequent collaborator Pam McKinnon. Upon first glance, his work in Downstate seems merely a slightly blown up replica of McKinnon’s naturalistic staging (kudos to Scott Pask’s lived-in, somewhat dilapidated living room set). But look more closely, and you’ll see that Mantello’s production — which is as finely calibrated and meticulously sculpted as Norris’s script — has been re-focused to highlight the play’s tragicomic elements of the play, more than ever instigating laughter as it distresses.

The cast is exceptional all around, giving disturbingly empathetic voices to objectively unsavory and repelling human beings, who nonetheless strive for dignity in a world that will grant them none. At the center of the show are the unforgettably gut-wrenching performances of longtime Steppenwolf ensemble members K. Todd Freeman and Francis Guinan, two remarkable actors who have been with the show since it pre-pandemic premiere in Chicago. The troubled conscience of the show is housed within Freeman’s truly astonishing truth-saying performance as Dee, a former stage actor who maintains to this day that his sexual relationship with a 14-year old boy was grounded in genuine love. Although overtly apologetic as Fred — a disabled elderly offender relegated to a scooter — Guinan also gives the character an unsettlingly detached demeanor that indicates a man who’s been reduced to an empty husk. Also worth mentioning are the other housemates, the boisterous and enterprising Gio and the timid and religious Felix, who are played vividly by Al’Jaleel McGhee and Adrian Martinez, respectively. Rounding out the principal cast are Liza Colón-Zayas as the thick-skinned parole officer and Thomas Sadoski as the aforementioned victim who seeks further reckoning for his abuser (Fred). Both are terrific.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

DOWNSTATE
Broadway, Play
Booth Theatre
2 hours, 30 minutes (including an intermission)
Through February 14

Categories: Broadway, Theater

Leave a Reply