THE HANGOVER REPORT – Hayley Mills headlines the sophomoric comedy PARTY FACE
- By drediman
- April 6, 2018
- No Comments

Klea Blackhurst and Hayley Mills in Isobel Mahon’s “Party Face” at New York City Center.
I recently had a chance to take in Isobel Mahon’s new comedy Party Face in an Off-Broadway production at New York City Center (the show is not to be confused with a Manhattan Theatre Club offering) before it shutters this weekend. What distinguishes Party Face is that its team is comprised almost entirely of women – it’s written, directed, and acted by women. I wish I could report that the results were worthwhile, but unfortunately, Ms. Mahon’s play just isn’t very good. Party Face is written in a sophomoric, totally obvious style that brings to mind the television sitcoms of the 1970s and 1980s. It’s one thing to be conscientiously imitating or parodying a certain style, but Party Face does so inadvertently.
The play, which takes place in present-day Dublin and tells the story of a house party gone awry, is at least competently mounted by director Amanda Bearse, whose production is handsomely-appointed. The cast is headlined by Hayley Mills (of “Parent Trap” fame), who shows solid, surprisingly nimble comedic skills in the role of a fussy, appearance-conscious mother. The rest of the cast – which features Allison Jean White, Brenda Meany, Gina Costigan, and Klea Blackhurst – are admirably game. If only the they had a better script to play off of. At its best, Party Face is mildly amusing, but mostly it’s a creaky, totally inconsequential comedy that ultimately falls flat.
SOMEWHAT RECOMMENDED
PARTY FACE
Off-Broadway, Play
New York City Center
1 hour, 45 minutes (with one intermission)
Through April 8

Copyright © 2026
Leave a Reply